Tuesday, March 10, 2009
Rorschach As Objectivist
I'm really narrowing my scope with this. To give a crap about this item you'll have to be:
- A comic book geek in general
- A Watchmen fan in specific
- A political junkie
- A non-leftist (libertarian, conservative, whatever)
Yesterday I called Rorschach a hard right-winger. Today I found an article by Brian Doherty written for Reason Online that argues that Rorschach is really an objectivist.
Doherty sees Rorschach the same way I do, but argues that the character is more politically inclined to the Ayn Rand point of view:
Rorschach would deliver (justice) as a personal, individual judgment; breaking what bones needed to be broken with his own hands, not from a world away with indiscriminate techno-gimmicks and no sense of actual individual guilt. The opposition between Rorschach and the villain is easy to read as that of individual, true justice versus the state's collectivist version. In every single war ever waged, governments make the kind of moral judgment that Watchmen's villain does, and the movie and comic, with Rorschach's help, make us wonder whether those decisions that governments and superheroes often make really are tolerable. Rand would have been proud.
It's a good read. Go check it out.
Labels: Movies, Politics, Watchmen
Subscribe to Posts [Atom]

