Tuesday, January 10, 2006

 

More On Captain Confederacy



Just a little more on this item from yesterday...

Captain Confederacy was written by Will Shetterly. Shetterly has a blog, where he mentioned that he'd seen the news story I linked to, and he contacted the reporter who wrote the story, saying in part:

I'm surprised that your article mentions my web site, but doesn't mention that my email address is there. If you'd sent me email, I would've happily responded.

Captain Confederacy is a science fiction story set in an alternate history in which the South seceded from the Union. The heroes are a multicultural group who ultimately overthrow the racist government. This may not have been clear to Jeanette Boswell because she bought the fourth chapter in a twelve-chapter story.


Shetterly calls the story a "teapot tempest," and he's right. I've already given it more attention than it deserves, considering that:

  • It's a story about a woman who bought reading material for her son without reading it first, so she'd know what she was giving him.


  • It's a story about a woman who seems to have presumed that the comic book is racist largely because it's about the "Confederacy" and the south.


  • She apparently didn't even read the story herself after she decided to become offended, or she'd have realized that the hero fights against racism.


  • Once offended, she apparently alerted the media... ostensibly because it's the media's job to raise her kid for her?


  • The media reports the mother's assertion that "whoever is writing this" should "stop putting out this offensive material" ... and the comic hasn't been published for years.


  • The media can't even agree among itself about the specifics, with one outlet reporting that Marvel's press release says that the comic wasn't created by Marvel employees, and another media outlet reporting that Marvel says that the comic was created by Marvel employees.


  • Meanwhile, I guess the media's work is done here as long as everyone who reads the story continues believing that anything southern... specifically anything involved with the word "confederacy"... is as racist as hell. Sigh.


    Comments:
    I'm sure all of the media outlets involved will print a retraction...

    ...one line on page 22C saying "Due to printing errors factual mistakes may have appeared in one of our stories from the other day."
     
    Sigh... is right.
    People get their panties in a wad WAY too much these days. Save it for when there's really something to get riled over.
     
    As a liberal, a northerner, and a comic book reader (who is just following the story as it makes its way around the web), let me say this: Jeanette Boswell does not speak for me. And I agree with pretty much all you said: She clearly didn't look twice at the cover of the comic book before buying it; she clearly assumes anything with "Confederacy" in it is racist; and she certainly jumped the gun by going to the news media.

    I wouldn't say she expects the media to raise her children (and there is something admirable about her choice to raise foster children). Instead, I think she holds an additional stereotypical view, which is that comic books are strictly for kids and should be devoid of any controversial content. I think this led her to bring her story to a wider audience, because she wants to raise the alarm that there are nasty bad comic books out there. It's a symptom of the widely held comics-are-for-kids mentality that the reporters found the story newsworthy at all.
     
    John Ham: I wouldn't say she expects the media to raise her children (and there is something admirable about her choice to raise foster children). Instead, I think she holds an additional stereotypical view, which is that comic books are strictly for kids

    You make a very good point with that. I probably did jump to a conclusion with the "let the media raise her kids" bit, which makes me as bad as her.

    Nonetheless, I can't for the life of me imagine why she thought this was worth going to the media, and the only thing I can come up with is that she was using the media to try to protect other kids from this terrible, southern story.
     
    So far as I can tell, the paper hasn't run my short little attempt to correct their misunderstanding. No biggie. It did inspire me to do something I'd been thinking about for ages: I'm revising the old comic book and posting it online as a free serial.
     
    Post a Comment



    Links to this post:

    Create a Link



    << Home

    This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

    Subscribe to Posts [Atom]